She knew exactly what she needed to do.
That’s what she told me in our first coaching session. Senior executive, fifteen years in her industry, reputation for getting results. She’d been passed over for a promotion she deserved, and she knew why.
Her boss was taking credit for her work. Everyone knew it. She knew it. HR knew it. Her peers had even pulled her aside to say, “You need to say something.”
So I asked the obvious question: “Why haven’t you?”
She didn’t hesitate. “Because if I’m wrong about how he’ll react, I lose everything.”
This wasn’t a skills problem. It wasn’t a strategy problem. It wasn’t even a confidence problem.
It was a courage problem.
And after twenty years coordinating federal disaster response, building a multi-brand consultancy, and coaching executives through the hardest transitions of their careers, I can tell you this:
Most leadership failures aren’t competence failures. They’re courage failures.
The Pattern You’ve Seen Before
Think about the last major organizational failure you witnessed—or read about in the news.
-
Wells Fargo’s fake accounts scandal
-
Boeing’s 737 MAX crashes
-
Theranos’s fraudulent blood testing
-
NASA’s Challenger disaster
In every single case, people inside those organizations knew something was wrong. They had the information. They saw the risks. They understood the consequences.
They didn’t lack knowledge. They lacked the courage to act on it.
I saw this at FEMA. Over and over. The moments that determined whether a disaster response succeeded or failed weren’t about who had the best plan. They were about who was willing to stand up in a room full of political pressure and say, “This isn’t going to work.”
The same pattern shows up in coaching. Executives who know they need to leave a toxic job but can’t pull the trigger. Leaders who see their teams burning out but won’t push back on unrealistic deadlines. Founders who recognize a co-founder relationship isn’t working but delay the conversation for months.
They know what to do. They don’t do it.
That gap—between knowing and doing—is what I call the Courage Gap.
The Four Dimensions of Leadership Courage
The Courage Gap isn’t one thing. It shows up in four distinct ways, and most leaders are strong in some areas and weak in others.
1. Speaking Up (Naming Problems Clearly)
This is the courage to say what everyone’s thinking but nobody’s saying.
Not complaining. Not venting in the hallway after the meeting. Actually naming the problem in the room where it can be addressed.
The failure mode: You stay silent in the meeting, then tell your trusted colleague, “I knew that was a bad idea.”
The self-assessment question: In the last 30 days, how many times did you leave a meeting without saying something you knew needed to be said?
2. Standing Firm (Maintaining Position Under Pushback)
This is the courage to hold your ground when the pressure to back down is intense.
You said the thing. Now someone with more power, more seniority, or more support is pushing back. Hard. This is where most people fold.
The failure mode: You raise the concern, but the moment you get resistance, you soften it. “I mean, maybe it’s not that bad.” “We can probably make it work.” “I’m sure you know better than I do.”
The self-assessment question: When was the last time you backed down from a position you believed in because the pushback felt too costly?
3. Stepping Forward (Taking Action Without Permission)
This is the courage to move without waiting for someone to tell you it’s okay.
Not recklessness. Not insubordination. Strategic initiative. Seeing what needs to happen and making it happen, even if it’s technically outside your lane.
The failure mode: You wait for approval that never comes. Or you do the work but don’t take ownership because you’re afraid of being blamed if it goes wrong.
The self-assessment question: What decision have you been waiting for permission to make even though you already know what the right answer is?
4. Stepping Back (Admitting Mistakes and Changing Course)
This is the courage to admit when you’re wrong and course-correct publicly.
Ego makes this one brutal. Especially for high-performers who’ve built their reputation on being right. But the best leaders I’ve worked with—at FEMA, in crisis response, in executive coaching—are the ones who can say, “I was wrong, here’s what we’re doing differently.”
The failure mode: Doubling down. Defending the bad decision. Blaming external factors. Anything except saying, “I made a mistake.”
The self-assessment question:When was the last time you publicly acknowledged a mistake before someone else pointed it out?
Why the Gap Exists
Here’s what makes the Courage Gap so insidious: It’s rational.
Every time you choose not to speak up, not to push back, not to take the risk—you’re making a cost-benefit calculation. And in the short term, staying quiet usually costs less.
You keep your job. You avoid the awkward conversation. You don’t become the “difficult” one. You maintain the relationship.
But here’s what that calculation misses: the long-term cost of not acting compounds.
The problem you didn’t name gets worse. The decision you didn’t challenge fails bigger. The change you didn’t make becomes harder to make later. And eventually, the cost of your silence exceeds the cost of speaking up—but by then, you’ve lost credibility, momentum, and often, the opportunity to fix it.
I’ve seen this in disaster response. The small risk you don’t flag becomes the catastrophic failure six months later. The coordination gap you don’t address becomes the reason people don’t get evacuated in time.
And I see it in coaching. The exec who waits too long to address a toxic boss ends up with a stress-related health crisis. The founder who delays the hard conversation with a co-founder ends up in litigation. The leader who won’t set boundaries ends up burned out and resentful.
The Courage Gap doesn’t stay small. It grows.
Measuring Your Own Courage Gap
If you made it this far, you’re probably thinking about your own gaps.
Here’s a quick diagnostic. For each of the four dimensions, rate yourself on a scale of 1-5:
- Speaking Up: How often do you name problems clearly in the moment, even when it’s uncomfortable?
- Standing Firm: How often do you maintain your position under pressure instead of backing down?
- Stepping Forward: How often do you take action without waiting for permission?
- Stepping Back: How often do you admit mistakes publicly and change course?
Now look at where you scored lowest. That’s where your Courage Gap is widest and where it’s costing you the most.
Closing the Gap
Here’s what I tell every executive I coach:
Courage isn’t a personality trait. It’s a skill.
You don’t need to be fearless. You need to be strategic about when and how you take risks. You need to build the muscle. You need to practice in lower-stakes situations so that when the high-stakes moment comes, you don’t freeze.
And you need to stop treating courage like a solo sport. The leaders who close their Courage Gap fastest are the ones who build systems around themselves—trusted advisors, clear frameworks, external accountability.
That’s the work we do in coaching. Not cheerleading. Not motivation. Strategic courage-building.
If you’re reading this and recognizing your own patterns—if you can name the decision you’re avoiding, the conversation you’re delaying, the risk you know you need to take—let’s talk.
Book a Discovery Call and we’ll walk through your Courage Gap together. We’ll figure out where it’s widest, what it’s costing you, and what it would take to close it.
Because the thing about courage? You don’t find it. You build it.
Brandi
Brandi Richard Thompson is the founder of Operation Growth LLC, a crisis communications executive, and a leadership coach with over 20 years of federal service at FEMA and DHS. Founder of Operation Growth™ Institute. Author of Operation Growth. She writes about leadership, courage, and the kind of excellence that doesn’t require your erosion.
For more, visit BrandiRichardThompson.com
Recent Comments